Colic & reflux

What is physiological reflux? GOR, GORD, and what NICE actually says

By Shel Banks, IBCLCUpdated August 202612 min readAll articles
Short answer

Reflux is stomach contents travelling back up through the gastro-oesophageal valve. It's normal: 40–50% of babies under three months regurgitate at least once a day, and it occurs in up to half of all UK babies. It peaks around four months, declines over the first six, and drops sharply after twelve. It only matters if it causes distress or poor growth. NICE is explicit that simple reflux needs no investigation or treatment.

Physiological reflux is the term for reflux that occurs in young, otherwise healthy babies with no obvious illness and no real distress — as opposed to reflux that signals a problem. It is extremely common, and it is not a disease.

All humans reflux some of the time. Drink a long glass of something cold and you may feel it wash back down to the bottom of your oesophagus. If you've ever had heartburn, you've experienced reflux — and you know that acid washing back where it shouldn't be is painful.

In babies it's more common still, and there's a good reason for that which almost nobody explains.

Why babies reflux so much

The usual explanation is "immature digestive system", which is true but incomplete. The more useful answer is evolutionary.

Babies did not evolve in environments where they were laid down flat and left there. Over the whole span of human evolution they were carried — mostly upright, on a carer's back or front — and they were in motion whenever their carer was. Putting a baby on the ground meant risking harm.

In that context, the ability to bring up and spit out excess fluid is protective. A baby held upright has gravity keeping milk down unless there's genuinely too much of it. So babies never developed tighter gastro-oesophageal valves before birth — they didn't need to.

Modern Western babies spend long periods lying down. That's the mismatch. The valve is doing exactly what it evolved to do; the posture has changed around it.

This is also why position matters so much in managing it, and why "hold the baby upright" is not folk wisdom but the single most physiologically sensible intervention available.

How common it is

Some gastro-oesophageal reflux occurs in most babies — probably all of them, at some point in the day.

That timeline isn't a coincidence either. It tracks the point at which babies can sit, stand and move freely — so the stomach is less compressed and less restricted.

Reflux is particularly common in preterm infants, younger babies, and those with neurodevelopmental disorders or hernias, including repaired ones.

Infant reflux is properly described as "non-forceful regurgitation of milk into the oesophagus" — and sometimes beyond. The word non-forceful is doing a lot of work there. See pyloric stenosis for why.

GOR vs GORD — the distinction that changes everything

These get used interchangeably and they should not be.

GORGORD
Gastro-oesophageal reflux. A normal physiological process. Milk comes back up, often onto shoulders and bedding — posseting. Gastro-oesophageal reflux disease. Reflux associated with respiratory problems or inflammation of the oesophagus (oesophagitis).
Needs no investigation or treatment unless there's distress, feeding difficulty or faltering growth. A genuine health risk — faltering growth, and oesophageal damage that raises long-term risk.
Resolves on its own. Reassurance is usually all that's needed. Needs medical assessment and may need treatment.

Alongside regurgitation, ordinary GOR may come with irritability or excessive crying, recurrent hiccups, frequent night waking and frequent coughing. The amounts brought back can look alarming — but they aren't a concern if growth continues to be good.

The trick is working out which reflux is GORD, which is simple physiological reflux, and which is a symptom of something else entirely — such as cows' milk protein allergy.

Red flags that need medical attention

Seek medical advice if the baby:

  • Is not gaining weight
  • Vomits frequently and forcefully
  • Spits up green or yellow fluid
  • Spits up a liquid that looks like coffee grounds
  • Repeatedly refuses feeds
  • Has blood in their bowel motions

These may suggest GORD rather than ordinary reflux. Always consult a medical professional if you have any concern about a baby in your care — there are other serious causes of forceful regurgitation that need ruling out.

Silent reflux

Silent reflux is where the regurgitation is swallowed rather than brought out of the mouth. The baby may cry and show every sign of distress, but never posset — so the obvious clue is missing. Symptoms are otherwise much the same as ordinary reflux.

NICE is careful here. It suggests reflux should not be routinely investigated or treated where a baby without overt regurgitation presents with only one of the following (NG1, 2015, rec. 1.1.6):

One of those alone isn't enough to justify treating a baby for reflux.

What NICE recommends

NICE states plainly that GOR is a common and normal physiological process in infancy, and that parents can be reassured it needs no investigation or treatment unless the child has unexplained feeding difficulties, distressed behaviour or faltering growth.

A common scenario NICE describes: a baby with frequent regurgitation is taken to the GP, and a prescription is issued largely to allay the parents' concern. If the baby is otherwise well and gaining weight, that medication is often unnecessary — and advice and reassurance would have done the job.

The stepped-care approach — formula-fed infants

For frequent regurgitation with marked distress (NICE, 2015):

  1. Review the feeding history
  2. Check formula preparation and feeding technique — over-concentrated feeds are common, and babies are often held in ways that make reflux more likely
  3. Reduce feed volumes, but only if they're excessive for the baby's weight
  4. Trial smaller, more frequent feeds, keeping the total daily amount appropriate — unless feeds are already small and frequent
  5. Then, and only then, consider a trial of thickened formula

For breastfed infants, the guidance is different and simpler: ensure someone with appropriate breastfeeding expertise and training carries out a feeding assessment first. Medication should not be started before referral to someone expert in breastfeeding to optimise attachment.

Note what comes first in both cases: assessment, not treatment. Someone appropriately qualified takes a full feeding history to identify potential causes that can be reduced by changing technique — before anything else is tried.

Overfeeding is a common cause in formula-fed babies. If a baby is fed too much — wriggling the bottle to get the last of the feed in, or infrequent large-volume feeds instead of smaller frequent ones — the stomach is stretched and uncomfortable, and the body's response is to push the excess back up.

Reflux as a symptom of something else

Cows' milk protein allergy

This is the one most often missed. The evidence shows that about 25% of infants with moderate or severe GORD have cows' milk-protein-triggered reflux, which improves after some days on a diet avoiding the allergen. For those babies the regurgitation is a manifestation of atopic disease.

Maternal dietary change is particularly indicated where there's a positive family history, eczema, or onset after the first month of life. Where a baby is breastfed, that should be one of the first therapeutic approaches — not a last resort.

Trapped air

Air in the stomach brings milk up with it as it escapes. Working out how the air is getting there is the place to start: crying, poor attachment at the breast, or bottle feeding with an unsuitable teat are the three usual routes.

Lactose overload

Poor attachment reduces a baby's ability to drain the breast effectively, lowering the fat they receive and raising the relative proportion of lactose. Undigested lactose ferments in the gut, producing gas and acidity — enough to scald a bottom — and the resulting pressure pushes on the gastro-oesophageal valve.

So reflux can cause lactose intolerance, and lactose intolerance can cause reflux. Both can be mild or severe, both can have entirely different causes, and they can occur separately or together.

Tongue-tie

There's genuine debate here. Poor attachment to breast or bottle may well cause a baby to take in air. But claims that frenotomy is the solution for reflux symptoms are not universally accepted, and opinions differ even within lactation consultancy. It should not be suggested by anyone who isn't expert and experienced in infant feeding management.

Pyloric stenosis — the serious differential

This is why "non-forceful" matters in the definition of reflux.

Pyloric stenosis is a condition where the pylorus — the passage between the stomach and the small bowel — becomes narrower. The muscle thickens, closing up the passage, and milk cannot pass into the bowel to be digested.

What it looks like

  • Small amounts of milk brought up after feeding, getting worse over a few days until the baby cannot keep any milk down
  • Vomiting becomes so forceful the milk is projected several feet
  • Milk may be curdled and yellow, having sat in stomach acid
  • Fewer or no stools, as little food reaches the bowel
  • Signs of dehydration: lethargy, fewer wet nappies than normal, and a sunken fontanelle

It usually develops around six weeks after birth. It affects more boys than girls and tends to run in families. Untreated, the baby becomes dehydrated and stops gaining weight.

This needs urgent medical assessment. The distinction from ordinary reflux is force and trajectory: posseting dribbles, pyloric stenosis projects.

Common questions

How common is reflux in babies?

An estimated 40–50% of babies under three months regurgitate at least once a day, and some degree of reflux occurs in most babies.

When does baby reflux peak?

Around four months. It declines over the first six months and drops dramatically after twelve, as babies become able to sit and move freely.

What is the difference between GOR and GORD?

GOR is normal physiological reflux needing no treatment. GORD is reflux associated with respiratory problems or inflammation of the oesophagus, and is a genuine health risk needing medical assessment.

Does my baby need reflux medication?

Usually not. NICE says simple reflux needs no investigation or treatment where the baby is otherwise well and gaining weight, and that medication is often prescribed unnecessarily to allay parental concern.

Watch: the hidden danger of using omeprazole to ease reflux in an infant.

What is silent reflux?

Reflux where the regurgitation is swallowed rather than brought out of the mouth. The baby shows distress but doesn't posset.

Can cows' milk allergy cause reflux?

Yes. About 25% of infants with moderate or severe GORD have cows' milk-protein-triggered reflux that improves on a diet avoiding the allergen.

When is baby vomiting serious?

Seek medical advice for forceful or projectile vomiting, green or yellow fluid, liquid resembling coffee grounds, blood in stools, repeated feed refusal, or poor weight gain. Projectile vomiting from around six weeks may indicate pyloric stenosis.

This article is for guidance and education. It is not a substitute for medical advice. Always consult a medical professional about a baby in your care. To find qualified feeding support, see Lactation Consultants of Great Britain.

About the author

Shel Banks is an International Board Certified Lactation Consultant with extensive NHS experience in research, training and project management, as well as private practice supporting families with feeding.

She is the author of Why Formula Feeding Matters, a co-author of the Cochrane systematic review on dietary modifications for infantile colic (Gordon et al., 2018), former Vice-Chair of the UK Association of Milk Banking and Chair of Communications for the Lactation Consultants of Great Britain. She teaches Babyem's Colic, Reflux & Infant Allergies course.

shelbanks.co.uk

Go deeper on colic and reflux

Start with our free guide and bonus masterclass with IBCLC Shel Banks — the four causes of crying, regurgitation and distress, and why medication isn't the answer. Or go straight to the OCN-accredited course, 54 lessons at Level 3 or Level 4.

made with